• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Create A Pizza

At Create A Pizza, your pizza dreams come to life. Nestled in Rochester, NY, this innovative eatery invites patrons to craft their perfect pie with a variety of fresh toppings, including the much-loved Supreme Pizza and the Sweet & Saucy Pizza, known for its delightful blend of flavors. Patrons rave about the warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Whether you're savoring a custom creation or indulging in their renowned calzones, each bite reflects the commitment to quality and customer satisfaction that has made Create A Pizza a local favorite for six years.

Create A Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Blake Fridman
Blake Fridman

Have been looking for a great calzone in the area and have found it (surprisingly they have been around for 6 years and I only just heard about them)! Staff was great and they make the order right in front of one. Highly recommend and will be going back! Tip: bring cash to avoid minimal credit card fee.

Carl
Carl

Let’s start by saying I hoped this pizza would be fantastic. I ordered online and came to pick it up. I was a bit early which is never a problem as we all know the best pizza is right out of the oven or as close as possible. While waiting I had the opportunity to speak to who I assume is the owner. He is the man. We chatted about fitness and such while he kept an eye on the oven. The time flew by. As a father of 2 girls there is always a 3 vote to 1 (me) going on for pizza toppings. It’s usually always pepperoni or just cheese. This is why I like places like this. I get to pick all the toppings I never get to order. My pizza had about 7 veggies and pepperoni and shredded chicken. It was awesome. They also aren’t afraid to let it cook all the way. I don’t mind charred bubbles on my pizza at all as long as they don’t go over board with it and this did not. This was my first time here and I’ll be back. I also noticed they have a really good lunch special for a personal pizza listed on the window outside. I’d come for that and eat the pizza right out of the oven. I have attached a picture of the special, the chalk board menu inside, and of course my pizza. Give it a try it’s definitely worth it.

Jorge Torres
Jorge Torres

This is a great place for a quick bite. As the name suggests, the place is geared towards making your own pizza, which can be fun. If you have a hard time making decisions, fear not, since they also have pizza combinations suggested for the guest as well. The menu offers vegan and gluten free options. The staff are friendly, and prices are reasonable.

hardie worka
hardie worka

Truly one of the most positive places on our route on Sunday afternoon! Very friendly people work inside and the menu itself is clear and informative. Their creations were perfectly balanced in terms of ingredients and while usually we leave the crust - this time we left plates clean!!! We also were experiencing some difficulties getting internet while mapping our next location and they did their above and beyond by sharing what looked like their personal hotspot. Thank you!!!

Coral
Coral

Wow. BEST BUFFALO CHICKEN IVE EVER HAD. I’ve seen this place for years. I think my subconscious was programmed to think it was trash bc I believe either dominos or Pizza Hut had been there previously. I was starving and wanted buffalo chicken pizza so decided to order it for pickup. When I arrived, the gentleman who I assume to be the owner was in such great spirits, it lifted my spirits. He remembered my specific request for 3 blue cheeses and drizzled some extra buffalo sauce on top for me. The crust was really high quality, the perfect amount of done but not over done, and nice and thin. The chicken was beautifully shredded and the buffalo was spicy but not too spicy. I am no newbie to pizza. I’ve traveled all around the world and New York State. Obviously New York has the best pizza. If you think differently - stop lying to us and yourself. I’ve eaten probably over 100 different buffalo chicken pizzas in my life and I used to work at small Italian restaurants who have their pizza dough recipes from Naples Italy. This was honestly the best. They take a lot of pride in their pizzas. I am so impressed and will literally always go back even though I live in irondequoit. TRY IT!!!!! And thank you for the best pizza. It truly made my day

codyiscold
codyiscold

Quick and great. John the owner is the MAN and he's right out of Queens. Want a New York pizza in Rochester? Come here. My girlfriend and I will definitely be coming back and we're just locals. She killed the whole thing before me!

Krista Rohan
Krista Rohan

Thank you to the management and staff for always providing a friendly atmosphere. Good people good energy & good pizza! Lots of vegetarian and vegan custom options.

Pedro Caquias
Pedro Caquias

I went on a 1st date and it was a fun, unique experience. The service was excellent and the food options were perfect for whatever your dietary needs are. It was also delicious and budget friendly! I highly recommend!!

Location

  • Create A Pizza
    766 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States Hotline: +1 585-730-5141

Welcome to Create A Pizza, an inviting gem located at 766 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY. This eatery prides itself on crafting personalized pizzas that cater to every palate, ensuring that each visit feels uniquely satisfying. With a phone call away at +1 585-730-5141, this is your ticket to deliciousness.

At Create A Pizza, the concept is simple yet engaging: create your perfect pizza from scratch. Whether you're a traditionalist craving a classic cheese or an adventurous eater longing for a medley of toppings, you'll find a canvas for your creativity. The menu also includes various options, such as a Vegan Cauliflower Crust Pizza and a completely vegan cheese pizza for our health-conscious guests. The emphasis on quality ingredients is a consistent theme in customer reviews, shining through in every bite.

  • Exceptional Calzones: Patrons rave about their perfectly balanced calzones, filled with fresh ingredients, highlighting the dedication to flavor.
  • Friendly Service: Consistently, customers describe the staff as friendly and attentive. One customer mentioned how the owner took the time to chat while watching over the oven—it's this personal touch that makes diners feel at home.
  • Freshly Cooked: Many have noted the joy of receiving pizza hot from the oven. This emphasis on preparation ensures every pie has the perfect charred bubbles without overdoing it.
  • Vegan and Gluten-Free Options: With a variety of dietary considerations in mind, there are certainly choices for everyone, making it accessible to a larger audience.

Whether you’re in the mood for a customized pizza, seeking out a hearty calzone, or want to indulge in one of their lunch specials, there’s a palpable sense of community at Create A Pizza. Customers appreciate not just the food but also the warm atmosphere that comes from a passionate staff. If you're looking for a spot that combines great meals with a friendly vibe, this is your place. As one satisfied diner put it, "the best buffalo chicken I've ever had" exemplifies the passion and care put into every dish here.

Don’t hesitate to visit Create A Pizza. It's not just about pizza; it's about creating a culinary experience that leaves you wanting more. Get ready to craft your masterpiece and enjoy every delicious bite!